Moving to Old Tappan NJ 🌲What to Know Before Living in Old Tappan NJ
Thinking about moving to Old Tappan, NJ? Nestled in Bergen County, this affluent borough offers the perfect blend of small-town charm and easy access to NYC. It is a top choice for families, boasting excellent schools and safety ratings in the top 1% nationally. Established in 1894, Old Tappan retains a quiet, residential feel while providing modern conveniences. If you are looking for upscale, family-friendly suburban living with an easy commute to work in Manhattan, here is everything you need to know before living in Old Tappan NJ.
Where Is Old Tappan NJ?
Old Tappan is strategically located in northern Bergen County, just 30 miles northwest of New York City. Positioned right on the New York state line, it borders the hamlets of Pearl River and Tappan to the north. For commuters, the borough is approximately 18 miles from the George Washington Bridge. It takes only a short time to reach the city, so it is never a long drive to the world-famous cultural sites of NYC.
While most residents rely on personal vehicles for local errands, the Rockland Coach 14E bus service provides a vital link to the city. Living in Old Tappan NJ places you firmly in the New York metropolitan area, but with the peace and space of a distinct suburban community.
Old Tappan NJ Population & Demographics
According to the most recent Census Bureau data, Old Tappan’s population is approximately 5,896. The borough has a population density of roughly 1,778 people per square mile. Despite this density, the area maintains a spacious feel due to its large residential lots and preserved green spaces.
The borough is characterized by a diverse and affluent population. The borough is characterized by a diverse and affluent population. People living in Old Tappan NJ enjoy community stability; the average household size is approximately 3.1 persons, and the largest age group is 45-54 years old. According to recent data, the racial composition is approximately 51% White (non-Hispanic), 41% Asian, 7% Hispanic or Latino, and smaller percentages for two or more races.
Old Tappan NJ Demographics
- Sex ratio: 50% male, 50% female
- Median age: 44.8 years
- Median income (household): $199,250
- Educational attainment:
- High school diploma or higher: 97.1%
- Bachelor's degree or higher: 76.9%
- Foreign-born residents: 28.6%
- Married couples (households): 84%
- Poverty rate: 2.4%
Source: Census Reporter
Old Tappan has been home to several prominent figures in professional sports and entertainment. Kenyon Martin is a former NBA All-Star and power forward who lived in Old Tappan during his tenure with the New Jersey Nets. Rob Segedin, A former Major League Baseball player for the Los Angeles Dodgers, was born in Old Tappan and starred at Northern Valley Regional High School. P.J. Byrne,A character actor known for his roles in The Wolf of Wall Street and The Boys, is an alumnus of Northern Valley Regional High School at Old Tappan.
Is Old Tappan NJ Safe?
Living in Old Tappan NJ, offers exceptional safety, which is often the primary driver for families moving to the area. According to 2024 FBI UCR data, the borough reported remarkably low crime rates, with only 3 violent crimes and 12 property crimes recorded for the entire year.
The data provided confirms the community's peaceful reputation, showing zero reported murders, robberies, or arsons in 2024. Property crime is similarly minimal, with the majority of incidents being larceny-theft (9 cases) and only two burglaries reported all year. These figures reflect a violent crime rate of just 47.76 per 100,000 residents, significantly lower than national and state averages.
The Bergen County Sheriff's Office and the Old Tappan Police Department provide law enforcement services and maintain a visible presence through community policing initiatives. This secure environment allows locals to enjoy the parks, streets, and school grounds with genuine peace of mind.
Cost of Living in Old Tappan NJ
The cost of living in Old Tappan NJ reflects its status as a premier residential enclave. As of 2026, Payscale data and local employment data indicate that the cost of living in Old Tappan NJ is approximately 84% higher than the national average. This premium is largely driven by housing costs, which are 300% above the national norm.
According to the Economic Policy Institute's Family Budget Calculator, a family of four in the Bergen County area would need an estimated annual income of $131,215 to maintain a modest but adequate standard of living.
Typical Expenses for Living in Old Tappan NJ
- Meal at an inexpensive restaurant: $19.00
- Cappuccino: $5.03
- Gallon of milk: $4.83
- Dozen eggs: $5.33
- Gallon of gas: $3.30
- Average Old Tappan utilities per month (915 sq ft): $127.94
*Includes electricity, heating, cooling, water, and garbage
(Source: Numbeo - Bergen County)
Housing Costs in Old Tappan NJ
When you begin your search for an Old Tappan home, you will find high-value opportunities. According to Redfin market data from late 2025, the median home sale price in Old Tappan is $1.155 million. The market is somewhat competitive, with homes spending an average of 89 days on the market, giving buyers slightly more leverage than in previous years. Whether you are looking to find a modern Tappan home with updated bathrooms or a classic colonial, the inventory is designed to match diverse needs. Once you secure your new address, you will see why living in Old Tappan NJ is great.
For those seeking to rent, the market is exclusive. RentCafe data for the 07675 zip code (which includes Old Tappan) shows an average Old Tappan rent of approximately $2,901 per month.
Old Tappan Neighborhoods | Where to Live in Old Tappan NJ
Old Tappan isn't defined by sprawling subdivisions, but rather by distinct "pockets" of character. Whether you prefer the scenic views of the reservoir or the convenient hum of the town center, here are the most sought-after areas for living in Old Tappan NJ.
The Lake Tappan Area – Scenic Estate Living
The western edge of the borough, bordering the expansive Lake Tappan Reservoir, is the town’s scenic crown jewel. Living in Old Tappan NJ here feels more like a countryside retreat than a suburb. The winding roads near the water are lined with some of the borough’s most impressive estates and custom-built homes, many sitting on acre-plus lots.
Central Old Tappan – The School District Hub
If you want to be at the heart of the community, the neighborhoods surrounding Northern Valley Regional High School and Charles DeWolf Middle School are the place to be. This area offers a classic suburban vibe, where students are often seen walking to school or practice. Streets here are bustling with activity, often featuring well-maintained colonials and split-levels.
The Enclave & Luxury Townhomes – Maintenance-Free Elegance
For those seeking modern luxury while living in Old Tappan NJ, communities like The Enclave at Old Tappan and Foxwood Estates offer a sophisticated alternative. These exclusive pockets feature upscale townhomes with high-end finishes, open floor plans, and community amenities.
Old Tappan NJ Weather & Climate
Old Tappan features a humid continental climate, characterized by four distinct seasons. Summers are warm and humid, with July highs averaging around 85°F, while winters are cold, with January lows dipping to 24°F.
Living in Old Tappan NJ means enjoying approximately 205 sunny days per year. Annual rainfall is significant, averaging around 47 inches, ensuring lush landscapes. Snowfall is a regular part of winter life here, averaging 26 inches annually, so residents living in Old Tappan NJ should be prepared for seasonal shoveling.
Things to Do in Old Tappan NJ
Looking for fun things to do while living in Old Tappan NJ? Old Tappan is a great place to relax, offering excellent recreational facilities and hidden gems for outdoor enthusiasts. Whether you are looking to tee off on a historic course or enjoy a summer concert with the family, there is plenty to explore.
Old Tappan Golf Course
A hidden jewel in Bergen County, this municipal course offers a challenging yet accessible 9-hole layout. Known for its well-maintained greens and friendly atmosphere, it is open to the public and offers a great escape for golfers of all skill levels right within the borough boundaries.
83 DeWolf Rd, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, (201) 767-1199
Oakes Park
Oakes Park is the borough's central recreational green space. It serves as a major community hub, hosting the popular summer concert series and town events. With a playground perfect for a family photo op, walking paths, and open fields, it is the perfect spot for families to gather and enjoy the outdoors.
184 Central Ave, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, (201) 664-1849
Stone Point Park
The active heartbeat of the community, Stone Point Park, is the destination for youth sports and local leagues. This comprehensive facility features baseball and softball fields, basketball courts, a seasonal skate park, and soccer fields. It also serves as the host site for the annual Town Day celebration.
Westwood Ave, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, (201) 664-1849
Additional Attractions Near Old Tappan
- Stokes Farm – A historic family-run farm (dating back to 1873) offering fresh produce, flowers, and a popular farm stand bakery.
- Palisades Interstate Park (Alpine, NJ) – Just a short drive east, this riverfront park offers miles of hiking trails, boat basins, and stunning views of the Hudson River and NYC skyline.
- Tenafly Nature Center (Tenafly, NJ) – A non-profit nature preserve offering miles of trails, wildlife exhibits, and educational programs for children.
Parks & Recreation and Events Calendar
Looking for more things to do in Old Tappan? The Old Tappan Recreation Department manages the borough's parks and organizes community programs like the Mayor's Wellness Campaign and holiday celebrations. Check the municipal calendar for upcoming events that help residents stay connected, a great resource for those moving to Old Tappan, NJ!
Old Tappan NJ Restaurants
Foodies moving to Old Tappan, NJ, will discover a culinary scene that punches above its weight. From handmade pastas to refined Mediterranean fare, the borough offers dining experiences that reflect its sophisticated character, all without the need to travel to the city.
MOOYAH Burgers, Fries & Shakes
A favorite for families and casual diners, this spot brings better-burger quality to Old Tappan. Known for customizable 100% Angus beef burgers, hand-cut fries, and real ice cream shakes, it offers a fun, laid-back atmosphere.
216 Old Tappan Rd, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, (201) 660-8488
Bosfa Italian Restaurant
Locals living in Old Tappan NJ agree that Bosfa is a beloved newer addition to the neighborhood. Known for its authentic, handmade pastas and wood-fired pizzas, it offers a warm, casual atmosphere perfect for a weeknight meal or a relaxed Friday dinner.
183 Old Tappan Rd, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, (201) 649-8730
Aurora
A hidden gem for refined dining, Aurora brings a modern touch to the local food scene. With a menu that highlights fresh, high-quality ingredients and a sophisticated yet inviting atmosphere, it is an ideal spot for date nights or celebrating special occasions with friends.
203 Old Tappan Rd, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, (201) 497-3658
Jobs in Old Tappan NJ
Old Tappan’s economy is defined by its status as an affluent residential enclave rather than a corporate hub. While the borough itself offers employment primarily in education and local services, it serves as a home base for professionals commuting to New York City and nearby corporate centers in Montvale and Englewood Cliffs. The largest local employer is the Northern Valley Regional High School District, which attracts top educational talent.
Job seekers can explore opportunities on Indeed’s Old Tappan jobs page or check listings for the Northern Valley School District for positions in education and administration.
Old Tappan NJ Schools
Education is a primary draw for families moving to Old Tappan. The Old Tappan Public School District serves students in grades K-8 across two highly regarded campuses: T. Baldwin Demarest Elementary (K-4) and Charles DeWolf Middle School (5-8). High school students attend Northern Valley Regional High School at Old Tappan (NVOT), which was recently ranked among the top public high schools in New Jersey by Niche. Known for its academic rigor, NVOT maintains a low student-teacher ratio and offers an extensive AP curriculum that prepares students for top-tier universities.
While there are no universities within the borough, residents living in Old Tappan NJ have excellent access to higher education nearby. Ramapo College of New Jersey and Bergen Community College are both a short drive away, offering diverse degree programs and continuing education. Locally, the Old Tappan Free Public Library serves as a vital resource for students of all ages, providing access to the extensive BCCLS library network, digital learning tools, and quiet study spaces.
Old Tappan NJ Statistics & Information
- County: Bergen County
- Area: ~4.16 square miles (Total) / ~3.32 square miles (Land)
- Old Tappan zip codes: 07675
- Old Tappan area codes: 201, 551
- Old Tappan elevation: ~52–100 ft
- Old Tappan time zone: Eastern Time Zone (UTC-5/-4)
- Closest airport to Old Tappan: Teterboro Airport (TEB), Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR)
FAQ About Living in Old Tappan NJ
Is Living in Old Tappan NJ Safe?
Yes, Old Tappan is exceptionally safe, ranking in the top 1% nationally. In 2024, the borough reported only 3 violent crimes and 12 property crimes for the entire year, with a violent crime rate of just 47.76 per 100,000 residents.
How Good Are the Schools in Old Tappan?
The schools are a primary draw for residents. Students attend the Old Tappan Public School District (K-8) and Northern Valley Regional High School at Old Tappan, which is ranked among New Jersey's top public high schools. The high school offers extensive AP coursework and maintains a low student-teacher ratio.
What Are the Demographics of Old Tappan?
Old Tappan has a population of approximately 5,896. According to recent data, the racial composition of the borough is approximately 51% White (non-Hispanic), 41% Asian, 7% Hispanic or Latino, and smaller percentages for persons of two or more races.
Is Living in Old Tappan NJ Expensive?
Yes, the cost of living is approximately 84% higher than the national average, driven largely by housing costs. The median home sale price is $1.155 million, and a family of four typically needs an estimated annual income of $131,215 to maintain a modest standard of living in the area.
How Far Is Old Tappan From New York City?
Old Tappan is located 25 miles northwest of New York City and about 15 miles from the George Washington Bridge. While most residents drive, the Rockland Coach 14E bus service provides a vital public transit link for commuters heading into Manhattan.
Map of Old Tappan, New Jersey
Discover What Living in Old Tappan NJ Is Really Like
Are you ready to enjoy the exceptional safety and prestigious atmosphere of Old Tappan? Whether you are drawn to the award-winning schools, the seamless commute to Manhattan, or the peace of mind that comes with living in Old Tappan NJ, the perfect place to put down roots.
When you are ready to make this exclusive community your home, trust our Old Tappan movers at Harrington Moving & Storage to deliver a relocation experience as refined as your new neighborhood. Our expert team specializes in Bergen County moves, handling every detail with precision and care. Contact us online or call us today at (973) 313-2246 for a free quote from New Jersey’s premier, highly-rated moving company, and let us make your journey to Old Tappan effortless!
Request Your Free Quote
"*" indicates required fields